Pulse 360

Showing posts with label Barak Obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barak Obama. Show all posts

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Queers: Beware Your Friends

"I'm a Christian. And so, although I try not to have my religious beliefs dominate or determine my political views on this issue, I do believe that tradition, and my religious beliefs say that marriage is something sanctified between a man and a woman."

That was the week that was. Also:

Virginia Democrats saw the worst campaign since Al Gore’s put out of its misery by a wide, wide … Oh baby could the campaign have really been that bad? Oh yes it was! … wide margin. On the upside, while he’s going to do incalculable harm, at least Bob McDonnell is not going to lie Virginia into a war.

New Jersey voters turned out their most embarrassing governor since Bill McGreevy. It was no mean feat to be both embarrassing and dull. At least McGreevy’s crash and burn had some tawdry juice.

Voters in New York’s 23rd Congressional District are still writhing on the ground, rending their garments and crying out to an implacable god, “Why us, Lord, why us?”

Gay men, lesbians and bisexuals who are starting to make up their minds are also troubling deaf heaven with their bootless cries. The good citizens of Maine passed Question 1, a referendum overturning their state’s law recognizing same-sex marriages. More than any election closer to geographic home, this result gave me a sense of my world and my options becoming a bit more constricted.

But was it a surprise? After prop 8 in California? After going down in flames in every state (31 in all) in which gay marriage has been put before the generous spirited electorate? This time it was going to be different? Because it was New England? Boy are we headed for more painful wake-up calls in Vermont and New Hampshire.

Let’s face it, beyond the thin gruel of domestic partnership (Can it be said enough? “Separate but Equal is inherently unequal.”), we can’t expect much from our fellow citizens. No more than African-Americans could. Or women. One shudders to consider the result of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 or the Voting Rights Act of 1965 being subject to a plebiscite. Every act of enfranchisement, of providing the rights incumbent upon simple humanity, never mind citizenship, since the founding of the republic has come from legislation or through the courts. The actions of a mob whether wielding ropes or tea bags or ballots are an ugly thing to behold.

Oh yeah, that Christian is Barack Obama.

Barack Obama who was the keynote speaker at this year’s annual dinner of the Human Rights Campaign, “America’s largest civil rights organization working to achieve lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender equality.” Much to the shock, shock of all, Christian Obama’s remarks contained reassuring platitudes without a word about implementation.

Evidently the Human Rights Campaign was taking the same approach as the Norwegian Nobel Prize committee, recognizing promise without waiting for accomplishment. I assume that each holds the unspoken fear that promise is all they will ever see.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

In a Crowded Theater.

""Ma! Ma! Where's my pa? Gone to the White House, Ha! Ha! Ha!"

That slogan was not prepared in anticipation of John Edwards being the 2008 Democratic presidential nominee. No, that scurrilous attack was launched by the campaign of the Republican candidate James G. Blaine against his Democratic opponent, Grover Cleveland  in 1884. It seems that a woman of Mr. Cleveland’s acquaintance was simultaneously acquainted with several of his colleagues. When the inevitable child came along Mr. Cleveland stepped into the breach and offered financial support, as these colleagues were all married.

The Cleveland-Blaine imbroglio raises two observations of contemporary relevance. One, Mr. Cleveland was not married at either the time of his acquaintance with the lady in question nor at the time of the campaign. This left him with no spouse to betray or humiliate. Well might one ask, where’s the sport? Good lord, even Larry Craig had a wife to trot before the cameras.

Two, since the slogan took a man’s decency and kindness and used them to cobble together a venomous and mostly inaccurate personal attack I have to conclude that Blaine’s campaign was managed by the great-grandfather of Karl Rove.

Former President Jimmy Carter recently offered some observations on the context of Congressman Joe Wilson's outburst during the President’s health-care-reform-I-guess-if-Max-Baucus-says-it’s-okay address: “I think it’s based on racism. There is an inherent feeling among many people in this country that an African-American ought not to be president and ought not to be given the same respect as if he were white,”

To be fair, Cleveland was only a candidate when subject to the Blaine campaign's abuse.  Are there examples of non-African American presidents being subject to extreme disrespect?

“Hey! Hey! LBJ! How many kids did you kill today?”

How does “You lie” compare with “Hey! Hey! LBJ! How many kids did you kill today?” on the respect/disrespect-o-meter? I know how I’d vote based on visceral fury of delivery, based on capacity to wound, based on capturing of the zeitgeist. But then, I don’t twitter so perhaps I am missing the piercing, elegant brevity of “You lie.”

“Hey! Hey! LBJ! How many kids did you kill today?”

This was chanted by hundreds of thousands (not 40,000 sad, motley tea-baggers) of (okay, pretty motley) protestors carrying signs full of hate and rage and loathing who surrounded the White House, furious with a man who was wrong, just wrong in the decisions he had made and the advisors he had trusted and who prosecuted an immoral war that ultimately cost the lives of 60,000 members of our armed forces. It is all our tragedy that that war is his most enduring legacy, for Lyndon Johnson did exponentially more tangible good for African Americans and for Americans living in poverty than Barack Obama will ever consider doing but then set aside because it won't be possible to achieve consensus with enough Republicans to arrive at a bi-partisan mandate.

So, Mr. Carter, if things head south in Afghanistan, I will be chanting because I oppose a war and don’t want to see young Americans die the victims of wrong-headed leaders and not because the president is African-American. I have to admit that my great fear is that if things do come to that point, many who oppose the war will not step forward because they won’t want to be seen opposing our first African-American president.

And I did see where you attempted to qualify your NBC remarks, Mr. Carter: “I think it’s unprecedented to attack a president, wishing he were dead, and equating him with animals and Adolf Hitler. That was the point that I made.” Sir, did you spend the years before and after your presidency in some kind of suspended animation chamber? I have personally held signs that were every bit as vicious and personally pointed and that often referred favorably to Hitler before (Nixon/Vietnam) and after (GHWBush/AIDS) your administration.

It seems to me that violently and vehemently objecting to the policies of an African-American president is not inherently racist. Quite the opposite, it is reacting to him as we in a free society are entitled to react to all public figures. Even Joe Wilson.

The president’s press secretary, Mr. Gibbs has made it clear that the White House is determined not to view citizens’ engagement in public policy, however intemperately addressed, through the prism of race. For that I sincerely salute the president. There are too many real issues of racial disparity, prejudice and injustice that need to be addressed in our society to allow this false issue to become a distraction.

Friday, August 7, 2009

Celebration and Sorrow

The Senate’s confirmation of Sonia Sotomayor for a seat on the U.S. Supreme Court should be a cause for celebration. That she is eminently qualified, both by disposition and intellect, cannot be disputed by reasonable people. Her elevation to the Court represents another important first in American society’s progress toward full equality for all citizens.
But that is also the first sorrow. It is disheartening that such firsts are still so prevalent and, in many cases, unattained. We should be beyond the point that the election or appointment of a Latino/a, African-American, Asian-American, Native-American, person with a disability or woman to any position would be headline news because of ethnicity or abledness or gender. It’s not an excuse that all progress takes time. Why? Why should it? What’s wrong with hurrying it along? I would argue that far from being a virtue, patience is a criminal folly.
I loved and love my University, but it staggered me then and staggers me now that I attended a school that had been integrated for six years and admitting women for two when I enrolled. The later lead to occasional confusion. As I was helping a friend move into her dorm room, her mother excused herself to use the restroom. She was back in the suite almost immediately, hands on hips, snarling: “I know that sort of thing goes on, but do they have to make it so easy for them?” Meeting blank stares she continued, “There are urinals …” As the only one able to raise his eyes from the floor it fell to me to explain that the dorm was built before the university admitted women and that the urinals were intended to keep undergraduates from pissing off the balcony.” I did not tell her they were unsuccessful.
I would make the argument that the courts, especially the California and United States Supreme Courts do more to promote progress under law than all the legislatures and referenda in our history combined. I give you Brown v. Board of Education. Absent Brown, my University might still be waiting to admit its first African-American student. I give you Loving v. Virginia, handed down in 1967 at a time when 72% of Americans opposed interracial marriage. If we had a national proposition recall system, President Obama might have been the son of criminals. But at least the wisdom of the people would have triumphed over activist judges.
On the day that President Obama was elected last November, an election that I celebrated briefly, the voters of the great State of California approved Proposition 8 which overturned a California Supreme Court ruling that had legitimized gay marriage (you see my reverence for the wisdom of the courts) and enshrined in the Constitution of the great state of California the admirable sentiment: “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.”
Particularly painful in the passage of Prop 8 was the revelation that the proposition was supported by 53% of Latinos and 7 in 10 African Americans, an almost eerie reflection of the 72% opposition to interracial marriage in 1967. Suggesting most clearly that no group has the market cornered on ignorant bigotry. Further suggesting that the moment any group perceives itself as climbing up the ladder, its first response it to put its foot in the face of the next group below.
My disillusionment with President Obama didn’t begin with the passage of Proposition 8. Although that was a shaky time. His response to Proposition 8 seemed to be that he didn’t think it was necessary but that he didn’t disagree with a word of it.
My disillusionment with President Obama began with his selection of Rev. Rick Warren, ole’ Saddleback Rick, to give the invocation at his inauguration. Rick can prove he’s not homophobic as “I’ve eaten dinner in gay homes.” Rev. Warren evidently regrets being 40 years too late to toss off “Some of my best friends are Negroes.”
Now I do understand Rev. Warren’s appeal to President Obama. Both Rev. Warren and the Obama Justice Department equate gay marriage and incest. But at least this wasn’t hypocrisy. I am not aware of Senator or Candidate or President Obama ever saying “Oh no, gay marriage is not just like incest!” I am aware of candidate Obama’s campaign commitments to do away with “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” and to support expansion of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act. Perhaps he’ll get to them in his 104th hundred days? I do fear that the Obama policy will be called “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, Don’t Wed.”
Beyond the courts, the real hope for those who want to give their children a fair education, or swim in a neighborhood pool, or receive equal pay, or marry the person they just happen to love, are the brave individuals who say enough, no more, and bring their lives before the scrutiny of the courts and the harsh judgments of their fellow citizens.
I hope that I will live to see the day when the generous words of the brave and private Mildred Loving come to fruition:
Surrounded as I am now by wonderful children and grandchildren, not a day goes by that I don't think of Richard and our love, our right to marry, and how much it meant to me to have that freedom to marry the person precious to me, even if others thought he was the "wrong kind of person" for me to marry. I believe all Americans, no matter their race, no matter their sex, no matter their sexual orientation, should have that same freedom to marry. Government has no business imposing some people's religious beliefs over others. Especially if it denies people's civil rights.